Research Papers
The influence of plantation site × species interactions on tree growth of various pine species in the Mpumalanga escarpment area of South Africa
DOI:
10.2989/20702620.2026.2749566
Author(s):
Heinrich HechterSchool of Natural Resources Management, Nelson Mandela University, George Campus, South Africa, Josua H LouwSchool of Natural Resources Management, Nelson Mandela University, George Campus, South Africa, Keith M LittleSchool of Natural Resources Management, Nelson Mandela University, George Campus, South Africa, Jacob W CrousSappi Southern Africa Ltd, Sappi Shaw Research Centre, South Africa,
Abstract
Accurate site × species matching is important for optimising productivity, resilience and sustainability in South African pine plantations amid variability in resources for growth and biotic risks. This study evaluated site × species interactions on growth performance of four Pinus taxa, namely, Pinus patula Unimproved (seedlings), P. patula Improved (cuttings), P. elliottii Unimproved (seedlings) and P. elliottii × P. caribaea var. hondurensis hybrid (PECH; cuttings) across three operational gain trials in the Mpumalanga escarpment area (Grootgeluk, Helvetia and Mooifontein Plantations) at a standardised age of 12 years 7 months. Trials were established on sites varying in altitude (1 206–1 640 m above sea level), mean annual precipitation (756–896 mm), temperature and soils. Growth parameters assessed included survival (SURVIVAL), diameter at breast height (DBH), basal area (BA), height (HT), stability factor (SF) and stand volume (VOL_H). Analysis of variance showed highly significant site × species interactions (p < 0.001) for all parameters, underscoring the important role of accurate species deployment. Notable findings included near-total crop failure of PECH at the high-altitude Helvetia trial (SURVIVAL = 9%, VOL_H = 35.1 m3 ha−1), attributed to frost susceptibility, contrasted with improved performance on lower, warmer sites (VOL_H up to 292.2 m3 ha−1). Pinus patula Improved performed favourably at cooler, higher-elevation sites (VOL_H up to 312.3 m3 ha−1), while P. elliottii Unimproved showed consistent survival across trial sites. Best site-matched combinations yielded >275 m3 ha−1, with poor matches resulting in near-complete crop failure. These results emphasise that suboptimal species selection can lead to substantial economic losses or crop failure, reinforcing the need for refined site-specific matching strategies to improve yield and resilience in pine plantations in the Mpumalanga escarpment area.
Get new issue alerts for Southern Forests: a Journal of Forest Science